twoWasaga Beach locations to serve you!
Main Store Hours Available on Google
Order a Custom
Take Home Tub
Please read before ordering!
Available for pick up only!
Sorry, we cannot accommodate same day orders through this form.
Please call if you are looking to order same day: (705) 422-0707
We will notify you via email when your order is ready. Orders are usually ready next business day. Pick up at up at our main store - 1004 Mosley St, Wasaga Beach
Custom Tubs: $20
In store special! 2 for $35
Choose from a range of popular flavours, available in our convenient grab-and-go cooler.
Order Form
Note: all tub orders placed online must be picked up within 3 days of being ready
Mix-Ins
Over 30 flavours to choose from. Combine 1,2,3 or more for your perfect blend. Have a flavour suggestion? We're all ears!

Apple

Cantaloupe

Cinnamon

Coffee

Coconut

Lemon

Mango

Pineapple

Maple

Oreo

Cinnaroll

Nutella

Rhubarb

Tiramisu

Reese Peanut Butter Cup

Cappuccino

Cheese

Blueberries

Espresso

Turtles

FudgeeO

Cocoa

Kiwi

Lime

Watermelon

Peanut Butter

Walnut

Crispy Crunch

Skor

Raspberry

Butter Tarts

After Eight

Lindor

Banana

Cherries

Chocolate

Ferrero Rocher

Granola

Orange

New York Cheesecake

Peach

Mint Oreo

Bailey's Chocolate

Toblerone

Strawberry

Pumpkin

Drumstick

Butterfinger

Brocolli
-
How much notice do you need for Cake/Pie orders?We ask for 48 hours notice on all cake or pie orders. However, we will do our absolute best to accommodate you if you need it sooner. Please call the store if you need it sooner (705) 422-0707
-
How do I order a custom Cake or Pie?You can order online using our order form, or you can give us a call at (705) 422-0707
-
How much are your cakes and pies?Our pies are $25 and come in one size. Our cakes are available in three sizes Small 8" feeds 6-8 People ($50) Medium 9" feeds 8-10 People ($55) Large 10" feeds 10-12 People ($60) Note: we offer a dairy-free option for our small cakes for an additional $5
-
Do you deliver?No, sorry! Cake or pie orders must be picked up at our main store located at 1004 Mosely St, Wasaga Beach.
-
What sizes of cakes and pies do you have?Our cakes are available in three sizes Small 8" feeds 6-8 People ($50) Medium 9" feeds 8-10 People ($55) Large 10" feeds 10-12 People ($60) We have one size for the pie, which is a standard size. Pies are $25. Note: we offer a dairy-free option for our small cakes for an additional $5
-
Is there any filling in your cakes?Our cakes ice cream and yogurt base is made with your choice of mix-ins. We also include a fudgy centre layer on all cakes. Please indicate on your order form if you would like to omit this middle layer. All cakes are also decorated using your mix-ins of choice to give it a beautiful finish.
Flavour Testimonials
Let's face it, with over 40 flavours, it can feel intimidating trying to decide on the perfect combination! Hear from some of our regulars on what they recommend.
Maple, Toblerone, and Cheesecake
"I've ordered this 100 times, it doesn't miss"
- Ryan D.



Pineapple and Mango

"It tastes so tropical and yummy...and they use actual fruit to blend in!"
- Vickie D.

Banana, Coconut and Cheesecake
"It's like a coconut cream pie but in ice cream form!"
- Janelle P



Turtles and Peanut Butter
"Peanut Butter is a MUST! After 20 years of coming here, it gets better each time"
- Mark C


Broccoli and Cheese
"It tastes like a cold broccoli cheddar soup"
- Anonymous


Pumpkin and Cinnamon
"So good around Thanksgiving, reminds me of Pumpkin Pie!"
- Samantha C

